Register Login
DioEnglish.com Return Index

sedgehead's Space http://www.dioenglish.com/?15461 [Favorites] [Copy] [Shares] [RSS]

Blogs

Plagiarism

Hot 3807 views. 2015-9-14 15:53

Plagiarism?  Can you spell it?  Do you know the word?  If you are a scientist or writer, you probably do.

I'm sending this note (bcc) to a couple friends I've done editing for.  The topic is plagiarism and paraphrasing.

Some people are under the impression that paraphrasing avoids plagiarism.  This is not really true.  To help me explain, I will give you Google's definition of plagiarism: "
The practice of taking someone else's work or ideas and passing them off as one's own."
Based on this definition [while will be correct by almost anyone's definition of plagiarism] paraphrasing cannot be used to avoid plagiarism.  That is, paraphrasing simply makes plagiarism harder to detect. By paraphrasing someone else's work, I am still plagiarizing it.
For example (from Wikipedia, on "A Brief History of Time . . . ." by Stephen Hawking (in green text as a direct quote to avoid plagiarism):
  • "The first edition [of this book] included an introduction by Carl Sagan that tells the following story: Sagan was in London for a scientific conference in 1974, and between sessions he wandered into a different room, where a larger meeting was taking place. "I realized that I was watching an ancient ceremony: the investiture of new fellows into the Royal Society, one of the most ancient scholarly organizations on the planet. In the front row, a young man in a wheelchair was, very slowly, signing his name in a book that bore on its earliest pages the signature of Isaac Newton... Stephen Hawking was a legend even then." In his introduction, Sagan goes on to add that Hawking is the "worthy successor" to Newton and Paul Dirac, both former Lucasian Professors of Mathematics.[5]

The introduction was removed after the first edition, as it was copyrighted by Sagan, rather than by Hawking or the publisher, and the publisher did not have the right to reprint it in perpetuity. Hawking wrote his own introduction for later editions."

My point (see especially the red text)?  No matter how many ways Hawking might have paraphrase the quotation by Sagan, it would still be plagiarism because it was Sagan's idea, not Hawking.
If you quote yourself from a previously published paper, no matter how much you paraphrase the idea, you are still committing plagiarism by " . . . taking someone else's work or ideas and passing them off as one's own.You can only avoid plagiarism by citing the previous author(s) of the copy-written idea (including your own work).  Paraphrasing it only makes plagiarism harder to detect.

Post comment Comment (5 replies)

Reply sunnyv 2015-9-14 16:44
Well, we have continuously been accused of pirating and copying without consent in this part of the world. Although there have been improvement in anti-piracy, we still have a long way to go. At least they should state the origin or cite the original authors.
Reply Scarlett_Lin 2015-9-14 20:40
A good way to understand the difference between the words. But I am wondering, what if I say those words just because I share the same ideas with others and do not know they are saying those before? Does the above situation belong to plagiarism?
Reply sedgehead 2015-9-19 13:16
Scarlett_Lin: A good way to understand the difference between the words. But I am wondering, what if I say those words just because I share the same ideas with othe ...
Plagiarism versus non plagiarism is hard to define in some ways.  For example, if one person says, "Give me liberty or give me death," does that mean no one else can say it (someone did say it, but I forgot who).  If I think socialism is a good idea, does that prevent anyone else from supporting socialism?  Not really.  The whole idea is to INTENTIONALLY copy someone else's idea and then present it as your own, as if you came up with the idea.  My point was simply that just because you paraphrase someone else's idea to make it so that computer's can't show you plagiarized something, doesn't mean it is not plagiarism.  

The reason I wrote the blog is because sometimes I receive long articles with long blocks of text that someone wants me to paraphrase to avoid plagiarism software from discovering they have plagiarized something.  That happened when I wrote that blog.  My point to the author was, "Why not simply cite the earlier paper?"  Often, you don't have to repeat information because someone else already published the details as in, "Smith and Gao (2008) provide details related to the methods used here."  Then you summarize those methods very briefly.  Details were already published, so there's no need to repeat them.

If I keep this up, I'll learn how to spell plagiarism!

By the way, science has a problem.  200 years ago, there might have been 5-10 botanical journals.  A good library could carry all of them.  Now, there are probably thousands of botanical journals (I'm not kidding).  Many are on line, but companies are making them unavailable by charging a fee to access the content.  What we are doing is actually making content less available.  But that's a different topic for a different day.  88.
Reply Scarlett_Lin 2015-9-20 13:24
sedgehead: Plagiarism versus non plagiarism is hard to define in some ways.  For example, if one person says, "Give me liberty or give me death," does  ...
Hi good day! I understand your point of view regarding plagiarism, just not paraphrasing to show that you are not in plagiarism.
I wonder when you bumped into that cases where people asked you to help them plagiarize, say a software as you have mentioned, did you simply decline the offer of help or how did you react? Yes, I think if you keep helping others how to paraphrase, you will become one of the crowd too. I dislike this kind of feelings.
Reply sedgehead 2015-10-2 14:14
I did the paraphrasing, but I also did some teaching, in trying to explain to the person how to not plagiarize and explaining what plagiarism is.  Ultimately, I am an editor and not a writer.  What the person does is their responsibility.  I just help them improve their English.  My job is to write and edit and not to judge.

facelist doodle 涂鸦板

You need to login first Login | Register

每周一篇英文日志,坚持一年,你的英语能力将发生质的飞跃!

DioEnglish.com --- A Nice Place to Practice English and Make New Friends!

English Writing, English Blog, English Diary, 英语角, 英语写作, 英文写作, 英语交流, 英语日记, 英语周记, 英文日记, 英语学习, 英语写作网, 英语作文大全

Website Rules|Contact Us|茶文化|英文博客网 ( 京ICP备06064874号-2 )

GMT+8, 2024-5-5 15:43

Powered by DioEnglish.com

© 2008-2013 China English Blogs

Top