Register Login
DioEnglish.com Return Index

rainecho415's Space http://www.dioenglish.com/?16988 [Favorites] [Copy] [Shares] [RSS]

Blogs

Dreams of the Red Chamber

762 views. 2010-7-13 18:09 |

    Having been cold for two days, maybe girls in illness are very fragile-hearted, I am very down recently!
    Finally, today I have the courage of writing down this article about the new TV version of Dreams of the Red Chamber, directed by Li Shaohong. Ever since it has been broadcast on PPS, I began to follow it almost every day, except days without access to the Internet. Although being criticised very heavily by some media, I still have to say, I am in favor of this version.
    The first time I contacted this masterpiece was more than ten years ago, when I saw the 1987 TV version, and I suddenly had a crush on it. I can still remember when I saw the scene with Blue Ridge Peak in the Baseless Cliff of Great Waste Mountain, matching the touching, melodious music, I was deeply moved and attracted!
    Then the book. Having read it for about tive times, I remain taking this great works as a pure love story, leaving alone the struggle between the aristocratic families, the declines and falls of typical Chinese feudal family through a couple of young lovers and many girls' tragic life. Although having seen some programmes about the exposition of what behind their history, yet I don't think I am that kind of guy who have interest in those more professional knowledge, which may ruin my mood of appreciating the purity of their love. I love the language Mr. Cao uses and the dialogues he writes. But I don't know how to express my feelings about this masterpiece in English precisely.
    Yesterday, I finished the 42~45 episodes, which happened to be the plot of The Death of Lin Daiyu, and I almost cried to death. The strong contrast between the "happy" wedding of Baoyu & Baochai and the dying of Daiyu touches me so much. What surprises me a lot is that those young actors and actresses performs very well, and their personalities are perfectly submerged into the characters they play, in spite that some people think they are not as good as the actors and actresses of the 87 version. Although many people don't like the version of last 40 episodes which is said to be written by Gao' E, I still want to applause to their performance.
    As for the incidental music, which draws the inspiration from Kunqu Opera, I think it is acceptable and get used to it after a few episodes. However, I have to admit that, adding the heavy metal music or the occasional smile of a female is indeed not that appropriate. And the Song of the Burial of Flowers composed by Wang Liping for the 87 version is definitely a classic, which hasn't been surpassed by now and will not be surpassed in the long future. I remember in 2006, one day I was watching TV, and I happened to find that one graduating class of Central Conservatory Of Music played this song all together, and I couldn't help crying for so long.
    Whether Chen Xiaoxu or Jiang Mengjie, they are all very suitable and excellent actresses of playing Lin Daiyu. It's weird that when I read Dreams of the Red Chamber, I don't consider Lin Daiyu as a so acrid and harsh girl, and Baochai as a hypocritical and slick girl. They all have their own charms, their own understandings about love, about life. Just like what Baoyu said, "Girls are made of water, while men of mud".
    Furthmore, I like the asides and the actor's lines, which is said to overly adhere to the original novel. And I think for those who have read the original novel, they would be very glad to hear the original words, comparing to the funny new version of Three Kingdoms!
    But, there are indeed many problems that are not very satisfiying. For example, many characters can't interpret their roles well and don't say the lines very fluently; the training of traditional culture and customs are not adequate. Nevertheless, to be honest, the new version has its own taste.
    Since this new version has already aroused my eager heart of reviewing this novel, so I decided to finish it one more time this summer vacation.
    What's more, I also borrowed the book Moment in Peking written by Lin Yutang. As we all know, at the very first beginning, Mr Lin Yutang was planning to translate Dreams of the Red Chamber into English and introduce our rich cultural history to the world. However, for some reason, he didn't make it. So he decided to write a similar book, and then Moment in Peking came out.The novel covers the turbulent events in China from 1900 to 1938, including the Boxer Uprising, the Republican Revolution of 1911, the Warlord Era, the rise of nationalism and communism, and the origins of the Sino-Japanese War of 1937-1945. It's reallllllllly worth it!
     I believe my summer vacation will be very meaningful!

共读西厢

Post comment Comment (17 replies)

Reply Nina01 2010-7-13 19:01
The book "Dreams of the Red Chamber" is really a classic by any standard and I like it a lot. "Moment in Peking" is also an absorbing book and the heroine "Yao Mulan" leaves a very deep impression on me.
Above all, wish you a very happy summer vacation.
Reply rainecho415 2010-7-13 19:05
Nina01: The book "Dreams of the Red Chamber" is really a classic by any standard and I like it a lot. "Moment in Peking" is also an absorb
Thank you so much!
Reply admin 2010-7-13 20:03
Maybe some day in the future, you can translate "Moment in Peking" to Chinese version. Provide Chinese readers a better translation version, better than Yu Fei's (郁飞) version or Zhang Zhenyu's (张振玉) version.
Reply rainecho415 2010-7-13 20:13
admin: Maybe some day in the future, you can translate "Moment in Peking" to Chinese version. Provide Chinese readers a better translation version,
wow, that would take a long way to go, but I want to have a try in the future. And also, I want to introduce Anne Rice's chronicles of vampires to China! I have to work hard!
Reply Great Tour 2010-7-13 20:39
I have a painting of this story and can see them everyday when coming home. The novel should be one of most outstanding  in the history.
Reply cabin 2010-7-14 07:49
thank you for your share
Reply ADabria 2010-7-14 09:44
Under the surpressing ethics of the feudal society ,Bao Yu and Dai Yu cannot express their sincere love openly ,and due to the traditional  ethics that marriage should be well matched in social and economic status,their fate was separated finally. Although the tragic fate of the female in A Dream of Red Mansions was related to their personality, in the final analysis, their fate was derived from the oppression and cruelly kill of feudalism.
Reply christie 2010-7-14 12:52
wow~~impressive ideas! You are a super fan of the book.
After finishing the final exam, i may also take a look at the new version.
BTY, have a nice summer!
Reply touringchina 2010-7-14 15:17
oh,book lovers all the way.it is till recently what a pity it is to have no appetite on reading books of classic.it is really a loss
Reply rainecho415 2010-7-14 15:21
ADabria: Under the surpressing ethics of the feudal society ,Bao Yu and Dai Yu cannot express their sincere love openly ,and due to the traditional  ethics tha
Maybe the love with no happy ending is more touching and moving!
Reply rainecho415 2010-7-14 15:23
christie: wow~~impressive ideas! You are a super fan of the book.
After finishing the final exam, i may also take a look at the new version.
BTY, have a nice s
Thanks! Wish you a happy summer too!
Reply rainecho415 2010-7-14 15:26
touringchina: oh,book lovers all the way.it is till recently what a pity it is to have no appetite on reading books of classic.it is really a loss
Well, boys mostly don't have interest in this book, it's Ok, just like I don't have so much interest in Three Kingdoms or Heroes of the Marshes.
Reply ADabria 2010-7-14 17:26
rainecho415: Maybe the love with no happy ending is more touching and moving!
ye,but if love stories are all tragedy endings ,that's too bad !
Reply rainecho415 2010-7-14 19:37
ADabria: ye,but if love stories are all tragedy endings ,that's too bad !
yeah, we still need happy endings!
Reply bluebird 2010-7-15 16:38
There're one hundred Hamlet in one hundred of minds!
I completely watched neither of the TV-drama version. I did read the novel at age 15. Those beautiful passages, esp. those graceful poems, brought peace to my heart during every hot summer afternoon.
Reply sue_bj 2010-8-5 13:22
LI shaohong,you destroy the Red Chamber in my mind!
Reply rainecho415 2010-8-5 22:45
sue_bj: LI shaohong,you destroy the Red Chamber in my mind!
Again, my dear friend, please watch the whole episodes and then make a more neutral comment!

facelist doodle 涂鸦板

You need to login first Login | Register

每周一篇英文日志,坚持一年,你的英语能力将发生质的飞跃!

DioEnglish.com --- A Nice Place to Practice English and Make New Friends!

English Writing, English Blog, English Diary, 英语角, 英语写作, 英文写作, 英语交流, 英语日记, 英语周记, 英文日记, 英语学习, 英语写作网, 英语作文大全

Website Rules|Contact Us|茶文化|英文博客网 ( 京ICP备06064874号-2 )

GMT+8, 2024-5-12 03:38

Powered by DioEnglish.com

© 2008-2013 China English Blogs

Top